With
today's GOP maneuvering, and the
governor's subsequent vetoes, it has become clear that this legislative session may well devolve to a series of plots, insults and vetoes, and it is difficult to predict what you lose when that happens.
Obviously the governor and legislative leaders have legitimate philosophical differences.
But how much are they really listening to each other, and talking to each other reasonably?
Barry Smith reports they met today, but how many decisions are based on doing what's right, as opposed to winning political battles?
Republicans are churning out bills. But they're turning conservative-minded ideas into mediocre legislation because of an over-aggressive style.
Look at the Charter Schools bill,
Senate Bill 8. It is a Christmas tree of lowered requirements for new schools. They'd have to serve students lunch, but not necessarily nutritious ones. They'd have to provide transportation, but only for a three mile radius. Schools couldn't discriminate against children based on race or disabilities, but they're also not required to accept every nearby student that asks for enrollment.
No wonder Democrats cry out and say these changes will simply drain the best students out of traditional schools, leaving the poor kids condensed together. Of course, the Democratic Party has had more than a century of rule to make North Carolina's schools better on their own, but that's another column.
Look at
House Bill 7, which the governor vetoed today. Is there really any reason to allow community colleges to opt out of federal loan programs, other than it will help banks who don't want to compete with the federal government? Is there
any evidence that a college has
ever been held liable for student defaults, as
some college presidents say they are concerned will happen?
If so, no one ever brought it up on the House floor, and yet the GOP moved that thing merrily along.
As for the governor, she's been keeping quiet, publicly, about most legislation until it's approved, which is not unusual. But last Thursday she spoke at Winston-Salem State University, and an excerpt was
posted to her YouTube channel. Said Perdue:
"I'm smart enough going into it not to try to pick a fight in the school yard. Because at the end of the day, I am the adult. And when push comes to shove. I'm going to do what we need to do. Let me tell you a funny story. ... You know I've been governor two years ... I've vetoed one bill and that's just because they were messing with me and I got mad. I vetoed it and I didn't even know where the veto stamp was. ... After some of this mess started happening (a staffer) came in my office and he had this brown bag and it was swishing. You could hear the liquid swishing and I thought, "Holy no, he didn't bring me beer or a glass of wine. I mean, this is state property." ... And I pulled the bag out and it's like a quart jar of red ink. Because the law says I've got to veto the, veto stamp, in red ink. And, so, I'm right with you brother. I'm right with you. I'm prepared and ready to go."
That's a great story. But I'm not sure it's one "the adult" throws out there, baiting the other side, picking a fight in the school yard just as you say you won't.
Speaker Thom Tillis mentioned Perdue's comments during a Tuesday press conference. I got the feeling he marked her words.
One day later, the House and Senate majorities threw
an end-around at the governor on next year's budget, tying it to an extension of unemployment benefits. The legislature has to make a formula change, or 37,000 people won't get their federal unemployment checks. Tillis and Berger said the state's Employment Security Commission took its sweet,
incompetent time telling them this. Everybody's accusing everybody of playing politics, and they're all right.
Later in the day,
Perdue told reporters that the GOP move amounted to "extortion ... dereliction of duty, all those words." She reminded legislators they "were sworn to take an oath, I mean they took it themselves on the Bible."
"It's tough being a leader," she said, "and sometimes I guess they're overwhelmed."
So we may be done here.
Perhaps more legislation will be crafted to put the governor in a hard place. Perhaps more legislation will be vetoed, in some cases for the wrong reasons. You look at the state health plan bill,
Senate Bill 265, which Perdue also vetoed today. Is asking teachers and other employees to pay a monthly fee for personal insurance truly unfair in this climate? Did the House and Senate really take just "60 seconds in front of a committee" to hear from retired workers and teacher's groups,
as the governor says?If the governor is serious about negotiating a solution, will she work toward one with the House and Senate, without insulting their leadership? Will they let her?
That would seem the adult thing to do, for both sides. Or instead of making North Carolina better now, they can
fight, and we'll talk about who deserves the blame. And maybe someone will make it better in 2012.